In the world of classic cocktails, some recipes seem similar at first glance, but every detail completely changes the experience. This is the case with the Gin Fizz, Tom Collins, and John Collins cocktails. These three names often come up in bars, but their nuances deserve special attention.
The Gin Fizz: The Simplicity of a Classic
The Gin Fizz is an iconic cocktail from the fizz family, which first appeared in the late 19th century. Its principle? Mix gin, fresh lemon juice, sugar, and soda to obtain a refreshing and slightly sparkling cocktail. The key to the Gin Fizz lies in its light and frothy texture, achieved using a shaker that emulsifies the ingredients before pouring them into a glass without ice, or sometimes with a little ice.
Classic recipe:
- 5 cl gin
- 3 cl fresh lemon juice
- 2 cl sugar syrup
- Sparkling water to top up
The Gin Fizz is distinguished by its simple and tangy feel, ideal for a fresh and easy-to-drink aperitif.
The Tom Collins: the full-bodied one
The Tom Collins is, in fact, a longer Gin Fizz. First appearing in 19th-century American bars, this version is served in a large Collins glass, making it perfect for warm days. It contains gin, lemon juice, sugar, and soda.
Classic recipe:
- 6 cl gin
- 4 cl fresh lemon juice
- 3 cl simple syrup
- Sparkling water
- Crushed or cubed ice
The John Collins: the originality of juniper
As for the John Collins, the difference is more clear: it uses juniper instead of gin. The rest of the ingredients remain the same: lemon, sugar, and soda.
Classic recipe:
- 6 cl of juniper
- 4 cl of fresh lemon juice
- 3 cl of simple syrup
- Sparkling water
- Ice and lemon/cherry garnish
These three cocktails share the same structure, but every detail transforms the experience a little. The next time you order a Collins or a Fizz, you'll know exactly what you're getting.
To explore this question in greater depth, an article examining the distinction between the Gin Fizz, Tom Collins, and John Collins was recently published by Michael Crespin, a cocktail history expert who works under the professional title MixoHistorian®. The study takes an in-depth look at the history and evolution of these three cocktails, providing further insight into the historical differences between their recipes. Read the full article: Gin Fizz vs Tom Collins vs John Collins: The Real Difference
FR
EN